World Dance Alliance Global Summit 2017
St John’s College, Newfoundland, Canada. 23-28 July 2017
PPT Presentation: Ageism and the Mature Dancer
Link to World Dance Alliance Global Summit
Abstract
This paper examines the role of dancers who extend beyond the paradigm of age as they continue to contribute to current dialogues in the field of dance. The intention is to create new awareness and to make visible the mature dancer by promoting and celebrating the older dancing body. Traditionally, ageing holds prejudice and no more so than in Western society where the preoccupation with youth is rampant. This phenomenon is particularly evident in the modern dance world. Middle age, or over 35 years of age, generally governs whether the performer continues or terminates their career, despite their physicality or performance ability. For generations, dance has been a discriminatory industry, irrespective of gender or physicality. This Western cultural norm has engendered prejudice towards the physicality of mature dancers’ bodies, disregarding a lifetime of embodied dance experience. Which is the preferred or appropriate body to perform, the younger or the older? Should this still be the case or is it inappropriate behaviour? The primary research process was through gathering qualitative data via a questionnaire and interviews with male and female mature dancers from Australia, UK, Canada, Holland, Sweden, Germany and the USA. In the survey the dancers address their ageing, physicality, injuries and process in the dance world they inhabit. It is known that dancers ‘talk’ through their bodies, and in the data gathered in this research provides the mature dancer with a voice; one that is rarely heard or acknowledged. There is a need for the mature dancer to be recognized not only for their ‘corporeal difference’ but also for their ongoing practice. Their embodiment and lived dance experience and should be viewed as a positive addition to their craft, and as such, an ingredient that can only be attained by an older dancer. The findings in the research indicate there is a new interest in the lived body experience of mature dancers and this is adding new value to Western contemporary dance culture. It will be interesting to see if a shift in attitude from the grass roots of dance training will be welcomed and or acknowledged.
World Dance Alliance 2017 Powerpoint Script 2017
SLIDE 1 - World Dance Alliance Global Summit header
SLIDE 2 - Ageism and the Dancer
My name is Sonia York-Pryce, I am a Trans Media artist and PhD Candidate at Queensland College of Art, Griffith University, Australia
The research examines the role of dancers who extend beyond the paradigm of age and their contribution to current dialogues in the field of dance
WHY THIS PROJECT?
We all know that ageing is a Taboo subject –but it is undoubtedly tolerated far less, if at all in the dance world. The considered norm to retire in dance is 35-40, but we know many chose to end their careers earlier. As an older dancer myself, I am investigating attitudes towards older experienced dancers and as to why they are not valued more in the current dance world.I am seeking:
VALUE, VALIDATION and VISIBILITY of the mature dancer.
SLIDE 3 – Decrepitude
So, I began in 2014 with this wonderful word – Decrepitude –
It means literally “The quality or condition of being weakened, worn out, impaired, or broken down by old age, illness or hard use”
PICK ME!
Explain
I started my young life dreaming of becoming a ballerina – I studied classical ballet and contemporary dance extensively in the UK and later progressed to teaching dance for many years when I migrated to Australia in the 1990s. My urge to keep dancing was strong even though opportunities to perform were few almost non-existent. My last performance in 2007 made me wonder what else was there I could achieve and still be within a dance context.
HISTORY
In the western world, it has been culturally understood for a long time that dancers, particularly classically trained were expected to retire around the age of 35 years as their stamina and physique begins to wane. Contemporary dancers too were encouraged to accept the rigors of ageing at around 40 years and to consider teaching or choreography. There have always been exceptions to the rule, but they were thin on the ground. Margot Fonteyn performing in late life, - Merce Cunningham in his 70s and Martha Graham in her 80s.
Witnessing Lynn Seymour’s, incredible performance in Eugene Onegin aged 50 with English National Ballet in 1989 was exceptional. That performance was both incredible and inspirational but not without criticism. BUT They were mavericks.
In the last few years’ dancers have been eschewing these long-held assumptions and are challenging both themselves and audiences to accept that a dancer’s lot is ongoing, and that ageing should not determine the end of their careers. You only have to look at the present day with Mikhail Baryshnikov still dancing in his 60s and now Alessandra Ferri dancing Juliet at 53 and Woolf Works for the Royal Ballet Company. But they are but a few of the incredible dancers in the research who are bucking the system.
There is a flux in western dance culture where perceptions of youth versus mature dancer are seriously being questioned. So Why should all that dance knowledge and lived body experience be shelved? Why is ageing taboo in dance?
SLIDE 4 - ME
At 29 years of age I returned to study at Laban in London – where I felt prejudice at being a mature dancer even then – I was affectionately known as “P” P for Pensioner!! THEN I remembered the underlying rationale that as young dancers an inbred aversion to older dancers was employed without really any discussion as to why this opinion was the norm.
I was also possibly the oldest dancer to audition for Laban’s Transitions Company 1989 – but I felt I was dancing was at a high level and I wanted a chance, an opportunity to be visible.
SLIDE 5 - Sonia York-Pryce at 55
SLIDE 6 - Does the dancing have to stop?
SLIDE 7 – Canada’s Louise Lecavalier
The two dancers who assisted me at the very beginning of this project, are firstly:
Louise Lecavalier, La La La Human Steps and Fou Glorieux
In 2013 whilst performing at the Adelaide Festival in Australia I secured an interview, and was invited to watch her rehearse and perform. Sometime later she emailed her responses for the primary research which were so in depth, insightful and important, not forgetting that Lecavalier’s first language is French.
She stressed:
I’m still looking for the dance, the dance that my body hasn’t done or understood yet, not a dance to surprise an audience but one to extend myself, body and mind altogether.
For her right now, she feels there is no end to her dancing, she stressed that she feels she is still perfecting and tweaking her craft – she feels in a good place right now but when she senses enough is enough - then let it be so.
SLIDE 8 – England’s Jennifer Jackson
The second dancer is Jennifer Jackson – former soloist with the Royal Ballet Company, Dancing the Invisible, Artistic Director of Images Dance The London Studio Centre.
When we reconnected, she was collaborating with other mature dancers and performing under the umbrella of Dancing the Invisible with fellow RB dancer Susie Crow.Jennifer’s visual documentation through film and her writing encouraged my interest in mature dance and alerted me to the possibilities of other people being interested in documenting these practitioners. It impressed on me the opportunity of opening up a dialogue concerning the established western dance age parameters to question why the dancing should not stop!
Her involvement with the primary and creative component in the PhD has been incredibly valuable.
Dancer Gill Clarke, stated:
The premature retirement of dancers was a colossal waste - not only of the dancer but their wealth of experience and knowledge and the futility of terminating their careers so early was an issue that would never happen in other areas of life
Youthful versus ageing
Marcia Siegel stresses:
Dance is obsessed with youth, like all the narcissistic enclaves of our society. Dance as sport, dance as glamour factory – a passion compounded of physical mastery and an idealization of the human form.
SLIDE 9 – Margot Fonteyn
Prima Ballerina Assoluta of the Royal Ballet Company, shown here with Nureyev, some 20 years her junior.Here shown in her 40s - she danced on. There is no doubt her lived dance experience positively glowed at this time of her performing life
SLIDE 10 – Martha Graham
The Mother of American Modern dance who also danced into old age - though she cannily modified the choreography to suit her own body, and retiring at 80. Graham lamented:
A dancer, more than any other human being, dies two deaths: the first, the physical, when the powerfully trained body will no longer respond as you would wish, but I knew. And it haunted me. I only wanted to dance. Without dancing, I wished to die.
SLIDE 11 – NDT3 1991 – 2006
So that brings us to: THE FLUX – In 1991- 4 choreographers known as The European Quartet, JiÅ™í Kylián, Mats Ek, Hans van Manen, William Forsythe, who were all in their 40s, dancers and choreographers. They were questioning why this STIGMA should still be so – and naturally it held a personal element Kylián created a dance company specifically for his older dancers. Netherlands Dance Theatre or NDT3 1991 – 2006 His four chosen dancers were: Sabine Kupferberg, Alida Chase, Nikolas Ek, and Gérard Lemaitre. This had never been done before – totally new ground! Kylián stated:
These mature dancers hold that fantastic physicality and physical presence -
They have History in their bodies
SLIDE 12 – Sabine Kupferberg & Gérard Lemaitre
SLIDE 13 – Gérard and Sabine 2015
When I interviewed them both in The Hague in 2015, dancer Sabine Kupferberg remarked:
I think all the audience was not believing it would happen because it is a very courageous thing to do. We all were all over 40 and people were joking – that what is this, are we coming on in wheel chairs? But of course, these are nasty people and you always have those – but then we had a performance that was actually very physical and when I look back at the performance now, I think we were amazingly physical – we were not at all 40 or 50 we were looking like dancers of a normal mature age – absolutely not physically limited, absolutely not in an age when you would think they should do something else.
Gérard said: Kylián was a big God, you know, he saved our life, and that became the love story with JiÅ™í, with Sabine with all those people because we love to dance, and we have so much to say, such experience. Not that we were great dancers, but we have something to say in the dance world still–and those people who help us with NDT3 like Jiri, van Manen and Mats Ek and Willie Forsythe, those four great choreographers, at that time.
During that same period, dance critic Eva van Schaik stated:
That attention for the elder dancer should be seen not as a justified cause for the involved dancer but also as an artistic need for dance in general.
SLIDE 14 - KONTAKTHOF - the younger cast
SLIDE 15 – KONTAKTHOF – the older
Created in 1978 by Pina Bausch, for Tanztheater Wuppertal and Re-staged decades later with a cast of dancers all over the age of 65 – Bausch wanted to make the audience face up to their ageist thoughts and watch these mature dancers perform – the choreography exposed that older dancers were provocative, overflowing with wit, emotion and performed full gestural movements that spoke volumes. With regard to the older cast Judith Mackrell stated:
Bausch’s casting exposed the poverty of our ageist culture.
She suggests further:
The 65-plus cast not only gave the lie to the notion that we become invisible as we age: they demonstrated that we can look significantly more vital and alive.
SLIDE 16 - Bridge the Distance – Siobhan Davies 1985
Choreographer Siobhan Davies chose dancer, Patrick Harding-Irmer, former London Contemporary Dance Theatre, for the main solo in her new work Bridge the Distance, he was then considered a veteran dancer aged forty. Davies was adamant that an older dancer brought something quite unique to the work, viewing the rich element of lived dance experience as an absolute asset to the choreography. She emphasized:
That dance then was seen as a physical manifestation of youth, vibrancy, high jumps and technical expertise and I loved it when I see something that is as thoughtful as Patrick’s one simple move.[i]
SLIDE 17 - EMBODIMENT – explain
Elizabeth Schwaiger states:
That the dancers’ body, at any age, carries a specialized embodiment, their instrument is their physicality. The aged dancer’s body carries such a strong dance vocabulary and should be valued.
Schawaiger goes on to challenge:
That the performativity of the dancer could only exist because they hold a lifetime of dance experience within them. This is only possible because they are ageing dancers.
The lived body experience of dance and the kinetics of time and space, both inextricably intertwined with dance.
SLIDE 18 - For the primary research there is a QUESTIONNAIRE
Sent to over 35 dancers globally, some I know and others whom I know by reputation, I have asked them:
-
How do you find your dancing?
-
how do the public view your career as a mature dancer?
-
gender prejudice,
-
how do you feel as mature dancers?
-
Is there prejudice about being and seeing mature dancers?
-
What are Their fitness regimes?
-
has the approach to performing changed?
-
Staying a dancer or wanting to create or teach
-
How difficult is it to keep going?
-
How do you cope mentally to push the body to its extremes?
-
Does maturity help?
SLIDE 19 - The DANCERS
Here are some of the dancers involved in the primary research
Remember, dancer’s talk with their bodies – that’s a given – BUT to actually hear them speak, discuss their process, their bodies etc., is unusual and deeply relevant.
Leanne Benjamin, Prima Ballerina the Royal Ballet Co, 48
She believed her performances were of a high standard, not just performing well for a forty-seven-year old! Benjamin was adamant that audiences kept her wanting to be there – on stage.[ii]
SLIDE 20 - Naomi Sorkin. American Ballet Theatre.
Just having performed for the first time in a few years, I was amazed at the peer as well as public appreciation of what I was able to bring to the stage. So much more physical limitation but a kind of emotional freedom.
SLIDE 21 – Ty Boomershine, Dance On Ensemble Berlin
Ty remarks: With regard to press conferences and the public
It’s the first time you are probably going to see yourselves on stage – audiences comment that it is so interesting to see ‘myself’ I see in your faces ‘me’ I don’t see children.
SLIDE 22 - Susie Crow Former Soloist with the Sadler’s Wells Royal Ballet, Ballet in Small Spaces
I have realised how important it is to keep dancing and feeling it in the body, to feed one’s practice and understanding
SLIDE 23 - Glen Murray – Australian Ballet, former Sydney Dance, Invisible Practice 55
I was a lucky dancer, but as a dancer I didn’t really understand anything until I was 30 and I retired at 35 from my first career. But the vehicle moved and continued to be trained. But now my physicality is fine, no more technical tricks but artistry is forefront.
SLIDE 24 - Charlotta Öfverholm, DV8 Compagnie Jus de la Vie Stockholm– 51
I listen more to my body now than I did before. But I have no problem to push myself and I think my performance as a performer - that I am better as an artist on stage now than before.
SLIDE 25 - Wendy Houstoun 59 UK independent dance artist
I guess more thoughtful. But I also like moving for it’s own sake. The movement creates the thoughts - in some ways - and turns into a game of moving between thought and move.
SLIDE 26 - Patrick Harding-Irmer former LCDT & Australian Dance Artists 68
Patrick says:
Being aware that movement is not particularly interesting unless it is driven by some kind of idea and also relishing in the fact that often slow concentrated and focused movement imprints itself more effectively onto the perception of an audience
SLIDE 27 - Liz Aggiss UK 61 solo dance artist
I know the audience needs time to understand this body is a different kind of a body and this is a solo female body who is inhabiting work in a very different way
SLIDE 28 - Rafi Sady 53 former Batsheva, Cullberg ballet and currently touring with Charlotta Ofverholm with Age on Stage and is also assistant to Mats Ek
SLIDE 29 - Nicholas Minns former les Grands Ballets de Canadiens – 63
I don’t consider myself as a dancer foremost, but rather as a human being who dances. The goal is always to develop as a human being and to express that in performance.
SLIDE 30 -- Pat Catterson – Judson Dance, Yvonne Rainer 74
I am not happy unless I can dance so I plan to do it until I die. I don’t care if no one ever wants to watch me dance again. I AM GOING TO DANCE BECAUSE I LOVE TO DANCE
SLIDE 31 Siv Anders former Cullberg ballerina 79- recently seen performing Hege Haargenrud’s beautiful work: Use my body whilst it’s still young which featured in London’s Dance Umbrella in 2016.
SLIDE 32 - Eileen Kramer Australia’s 102-year-old former Bodenweiser dancer and still dancing and choreographing!
I interviewed Eileen in 2015 – she said when discussing age:
I thought I was 35!! (Eileen)
Well what is my age – (if asked) – I don’t know!
Movement makes you feel so much better – quite recently I started exercising in bed, Then I get up and do a few barre exercises …its so good for the feet, such wonderful exercise.
SLIDE 33 - CORPOREAL VALUE –
The shift in the western dance world is acknowledging that mature dance is integral with creativity, life experience and corporeal difference, thus enriching the cultural landscape by keeping these mature movers visible
Dancers and educators: Dr Mark Edward and Helen Newell discuss the mature dancers “corporeal ability,” their embodied experience and maturity and state how under-valued their presence is and would be if they were totally alienated. Mark stresses that mature performers become more fascinating as they age, and the work develops more around them, as the individual dancer rather than the actual choreographed work.
Nanako Nakajima discusses ageing in dance and stresses that:
dancing beauty can be old –
SLIDE 34 –in 2015 Dance On Ensemble, Berlin is formed– funded by the German Government - the first mature dance company since NDT3 1991 – all of the dancers are over 40. They are currently on tour in Europe with Charlotta Öfverholm, who form part of the Dance On, Pass On, Dream On, EU Project, Creative Europe, valuing age and embodied knowledge on stage and in society.
http://www.creativeeuropeuk.eu/funded-projects/dance-pass-dream
SLIDE 35- Quote by dancer Ann Dickie who features in both the primary and creative research
“At last, people are beginning to recognize what some of us have always known – The value of the creativity and experience of older people
SLIDE 36 – INTERPRÈTE/INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOUR trailer
A visual documentation celebrating the mature dancer’s corporeal difference and how their PRACTICE rather than their age defines them.
Thank you so much!
[i] Find link to Siobhan Davies film - archive